Season 1

Michael McStay

Self - Brother of Joseph McStay

Gina Watson

Self - Friend of Joseph

Patrick McStay

Self - Father of Joseph McStay

Chase Merritt

Self - Convicted of a Quadruple Murder

Michael A. Smith

Self - Judge for San Bernardino County Courts, California

Dan Kavanaugh

Self - Employee of Joseph McStay

John McMahon

Self - Sheriff at the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department